On Wednesday, March 3, a new exposing article appeared in the LiveJournal of oppositionist Alexei Navalny, which tells in detail that Pavel Astakhov, a children's uniform, doctor of law, stole his dissertation, to say the least.
In his today's publication, Alexey Navalny points out in points that the doctoral dissertation, which Astakhov defended in 2006, is not only almost completely plagiarized, but does not carry any practical value and scientific novelty. Borrowing was not found only in a small part of the “scientific work”, and then, as the blogger notes, “it has not yet been discovered.”
To prove that Astakhov's dissertation is not a worthy scientific work, Navalny gives a lot of illustrations.

The dissertation of Pavel Astakhov is a copy-paste.The dissertation of Pavel Astakhov is a copy-paste.
Meanwhile, Navalny himself never uses the word "plagiarism" in relation to Pavel Astakhov.The oppositionist himself explains this with the following reasons: “that there is no smell of plagiarism here: there is no stealing of ideas, no attempt to use other people's methods and solutions for your own work. Because there is no “own work”: there are fatty chunks of other people's texts tightly fitted to each other, reproduced literally, page by page, and sometimes dozens of pages in a row. ”
In his publication, the blogger not only tells specific pieces of copy-paste, but also cites sources, from which, without any changes, references and quotation marks were taken pieces of text.
Astakhov’s doctoral dissertation was also assessed by some experts: “The coloring style varies considerably from Chapter to Chapter,” he wrote. “For example, Section II, Chapter II: worked with large strokes, copied with page-by-page blocks. Another thing is Section I, Chapter III: master copies from the original source only the first sentences of different paragraphs. ”
There are similar questions to the master’s thesis, which the children's overalls defended in 2002.
Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation.Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation.
However, according to Russian bloggers, in 2002, lawyer Astakhov defended his thesis, and in 2006 his doctoral thesis was only to see his name in the line “author”.
True, not everyone appreciated the new expose in the Navalny blog. User LJ Kostomarov commented: “Not having time to figure it out, he starts throwing mud from the rocket launcher, in vain accusing a worthy person of sins!”.
Meanwhile, after Navalny was in dual citizenship and in owning real estate abroad, a member of the Federation Council had to leave a warm place.

Related news

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 image, picture, imagery


Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 86

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 5

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 45

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 23

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 59

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 42

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 80

Exposing: Alexei Navalny accuses Pavel Astakhov of having stolen his dissertation on 03.04.2013 89